• S.

    PROF. DR. FREUD
    WIEN, IX., BERGGASSE 19.

    Febr 5th 1922

    Dear Mrs Blumgart

    I thank you for the frank in-
    formation about your situat-
    ion which enables me to give
    you as frank an answer.

    I am ready to accept you for
    analysis on Oct first for a
    pupil’s fee (# 10), your other
    plan being impracticable as I
    leave town on July first. 
    Your view of Leonard B.’s reation
    to your case is all wrong, I dare
    say.  He pleaded for you in a most 
    disinterested way and I am indeed 
    giving way to his influence when
    I in spite of my own scruples agree
    to undertake your analysis.

    But there are two points on
    which we are still asunder and
    which may prove to be serious
    obstacles.  I intend only to give
    you some hints of them while
    L. B who knows my mind will 
    talk it out fully with
    you.

    First, you seem to pursue too
    many aims at the same time
    (mehrere Hasen zur gelichen
    Zeit jagen), which will not
    work in our relations,

  • S.

    If you come here for being analyzed
    and learning how to practise
    analysis on others, that one got
    will prove enough for you and
    other medical work could
    only be granted as far as it
    does not interfere with your
    main object.

    Secondly, it is nearly absurd to
    devote a clear cut length of time 
    – 4 months as you intend – to a
    work which is la produce a
    lasting change in your emotion-
    al attitude to life and love 
    and at the same time to lay
    the foundation for you activ-
    ity as an analyst.  What you
    need is a whole season, 10 months
    or so.  If you cannot manage to
    do so it is better to resign. Your 
    tendency to grasp two different
    and contrasting things by the
    same grip, may be a reproduction
    of your love life but it will
    not work nor analysis. You would
    come to nothing.  It is a clear
    Entweder – Oder for you.

    So you see I may consider your
    application as an open question
    before you have not thought it
    over more thoroughly within
    yourself and with L. B  after 
    his return.
    Yours sincerely
    Freud